What if Batman had the chance to save the two people he lost before he ever became the Dark Knight?

Following the events of The Flash (2023), Bruce Wayne is confronted with an extraordinary possibility when a mysterious encounter with the Phantom Stranger offers him something he never thought he could have: a chance to change another world’s history.

Transported to an alternate Gotham City, Batman discovers a world unlike his own — a world without heroes, without legends, and without a Batman. But when he learns that this world’s Thomas and Martha Wayne are still alive, Bruce faces a decision that will challenge everything he believes about his mission, his past, and what it truly means to be Batman.

Based on Alan Brennert’s celebrated story from Detective Comics #500, To Kill a Legend is a powerful, emotional Batman story about sacrifice, hope, and the possibility of changing someone’s future.

This full-cast audiobook brings the story to life through cinematic performances, original music, and immersive sound design, imagining how this extraordinary story might unfold within the world of the DCEU’s Batman.

Sometimes, being a hero isn’t about saving the world. Sometimes, it’s about saving just two people.

Adapting To Kill a Legend to the DCEU

To Kill a Legend is probably my favorite single-issue Batman story. It has all the elements I love about the character- his desire to turn his pain into something positive and heroic, his inability to let people die, and of course, detective work, fight scenes, and him mentoring Robin. It also has a compelling emotional dilemma with a fantastic ending and was cited as Mark Waid’s favorite Batman story.

Yet I almost didn’t adapt it.

Around 2023, Tim Maxwell asked me about shorter audio stories for different versions of Batman. Ones that weren’t full on movie or screenplay adaptations. I decided to adapt single issue comic stories into audios that could fit the different Batmen for the channel.

Keaton got A Vow from the Grave, Conroy got White Christmas, Kilmer got Night of the Reaper, Clooney got Robin Dies at Dawn, Bale got Fears, and Pattinson got Blowback from the Forensic Files of Batman book.

I did wonder if there was a place for To Kill a Legend. At first glance, it didn’t seem to fit any of the Batmen. Phantom Stranger wasn’t exactly a character you often saw in the Batman movies or in DC adaptations in general. Then in the comic, it was both Batman and Robin who traveled to the alternate earth, so that seemingly left me with the options of Adam West, Val Kilmer, and George Clooney.

But then it hit me.

This is Batman’s Flashpoint before Flashpoint was even a story. It’s his opportunity to save his own parents.

That plus the multiverse element of it made me realize there was only one Batman for this story, the one who had literally been offered this choice onscreen: Ben Affleck.

After having written for other Batmen already, I knew I wanted to do a Batfleck one, but what would the story be? The period of time before Batman V Superman seemed rife with potential. Would we cover his Batman meeting Will Smith’s Deadshot for the first time? Ewan McGregor’s Black Mask? When it hit me that To Kill a Legend could fit with Batfleck, I realized that it was Batfleck’s future after The Flash that might be more interesting than his past. We could literally start from his last scene in The Flash, when Barry offered to go back in time to save his parents. What if, after he drove off, Fate presented him with a similar choice?

I’d have to take some liberties with the comic to fit the DCEU, of course. Robin was in the original comic, but would he be in this version of the story when there wasn’t a DCEU Robin? Zack Snyder had famously killed off Dick Grayson (though I’ve noted to people that this could easily have been retconned since Dick was never named or confirmed onscreen). I wondered at first whether to add a Tim Drake or Carrie Kelley Robin into the fold, but decided to just cut Robin entirely. Robin’s purpose in the comic is to not only give him someone to interact with, but also serve as the skeptical voice who wonders if it’s even a good idea to save the Waynes and prevent Batman’s birth. Here with the narrative format, Bruce could grapple with that himself.

The comic also features Phantom Stranger talking about other worlds in the multiverse. There, he showed the Earth Two Batman from the Golden Age. But to adapt this, I thought it would be cooler for those worlds to show other movie Batmen instead, with the two other movie Batmen who had their parents murdered on screen: Michael Keaton and Christian Bale.

I also had to somewhat add a new element to the DCEU Batman’s backstory, which was Joe Chill and Lew Moxon. I know most people prefer the more modern take on the murders in the killer being unknown or Chill acting on his own in a random act of violence. But I grew up on The Untold Legend of the Batman, which retold the Silver Age take on Lew Moxon using Joe Chill to get revenge on Thomas Wayne for being the key witness in sending him to prison. This backstory was an essential element in To Kill a Legend. Affleck’s backstory was the only one that seemed to have room for this creative license. Keaton’s parents were killed by Jack Napier. Bale’s parents were killed by a Joe Chill who was just desperate for money. Pattinson’s were potentially killed in a mob hit, too, but as of now, the killer was never caught so his identity remains unknown.

Meanwhile, Affleck’s parents are seen getting killed in the beginning of BvS, but we never learn anything about whether the killer was caught from the movies, though tie-in materials alluded that he wasn’t.

Zack Snyder himself referred to the character, played by Damon Caro, as Joe Chill and I felt there was enough leeway in the backstory for Affleck’s Batman to have figured out that Chill was the gunman and that Lew Moxon had orchestrated the hit. One could even say that Affleck discovered this after Batman V Superman, which would render the BvS tie-in materials still canon to that period of time.

The Original Script for To Kill a Legend

The script actually went through several iterations. It originally started as a narrative piece, similar to Night of the Reaper, A Vow from the Grave, Fears, and White Christmas, with lines from just Batman and the Phantom Stranger. Tim, however, saw potential in it being a full cast audio drama, which allowed me to expand on different scenes. I added back in dialogue from the original comic and did my own spin on Gordon’s dialogue.

While Tim gave me the final writing credit on the adaptation, he actually did the final pass on the script in changing Bruce’s narration to a third person narrator. The narration in the final version is really his, based on this drift, and he added an expanded version of the recap of The Flash scene, since my original version was just hearing Bruce repeat his last words to Barry before narrating the rest of the story.

You can check out the script here:

Loading Viewer...

To Kill a Legend – Neuverse Media Script

Readers will notice that this is different from the audio and the comic. The biggest difference, aside from the narration, is the scene in the hotel with Joe Chill. As I was going through the comic, I realized that there could be more emotion to mine here since in the original story, Batman just learns the exposition from the dying Chill and then leaves. You can read my version in context with the rest of the script above but here is the scene reposted below as well.

Note that Bruce’s lines are as the narrator while Batman’s lines are the spoken dialogue with Chill in the scene.

 

BRUCE
With one last nod, I took off to face the man about to murder my parents.

The sound of Batman’s cape flapping. “Beautiful Lie” begins.

BRUCE
But I was in for another surprise. When I arrived at the hotel, Joe Chill was lying on the floor with bullets in his chest. He was still breathing. But not for long.

JOE CHILL
You…You’re the one he was talking about…

BATMAN
Who was talking about? What happened?

JOE CHILL
M-Moxon. I came to see him…he threw me out. Said some…maniac in a batsuit was after me. I got back…one of his goons was waiting…on his way to another hit.

BATMAN
Another hit? Who?

JOE CHILL
Some doctor. Guy named Wayne.

BATMAN
The hit on the Waynes…it’s tonight.

JOE CHILL
Yeah. Guy said…something about… going to the movies…

BRUCE
For years, I had seen this man as a monster. I’d spent my whole life forging myself into a bigger monster to take him down. To make him pay. Make him suffer. But here, in this room…all I saw was a dying man. The fear in his eyes had nothing to do with the costume I wore. It was fear of what lay ahead of him on the other side.

JOE CHILL
W-Who are you? How do you know me?

BATMAN
…You and I go a long way back.

JOE CHILL
Mister…Could you…could you just stay a little? I don’t wanna die alone. Please…

BRUCE
For twenty years, The Batman had struck fear in criminals. But Bruce Wayne? Bruce Wayne was a doctor’s son. A doctor who believed in relieving the suffering…

JOE CHILL
You…you still there?

BATMAN
I’m here…Chill…You did a good thing tonight, telling me about the Waynes.

JOE CHILL
Good thing, huh? How bout that…never done a good thing before…Never done a good thing my whole life.

Chill takes his last breath.

BRUCE
And with that, Joe Chill was gone. The man who murdered my parents on one earth was now the one who’d help me save them. I just hoped I wasn’t too late.

Going a little into how this scene came about, I thought about how much of a dramatic twist it would be for Batman to take pity on this version of Chill, to come into the room ready to enact pre-emptive vengeance, only to stay with him (and arguably risk delaying his ability to stop his parents’ murder) as an act of mercy and a way of honoring both his Bruce Wayne side and his humanitarian father.

In many ways, I see To Kill a Legend as an appropriate ending to Batman’s character journey, across all iterations. After all, isn’t the point of Batman to be the figure who can save another boy’s parents? But this scene with Joe Chill in particular also felt significant for the Ben Affleck version for his arc. Affleck’s Batman was notoriously slaughtering criminals in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. His intended arc was for Superman’s sacrifice to put him on the path of redemption and regain his humanity. While the execution of that idea is debatable, the concept of Affleck’s notoriously lethal Batman confronting the very man who killed his parents, but having a reason to treat him with mercy rather than coldness was something that appealed to me. Ultimately, the version in the final audio is closer to the original comic.

Another change came from a moment where the Waynes actually get to talk to Batman, which is different from both the comic and the final audio version. I admit the whole “I’m…I’m The Batman” was very much inspired by Season 1 of The Flash when Grant Gustin’s Flash says, “I’m…I’m The Flash” when he comforts his dying mother in the past. But the final audio version does not have them interact, though it keeps the emotional beat I wrote in of Batman absorbing the sight of his family alive and safe before he disappears.

Now, when he’s taking Bruce away, The Phantom Stranger says, “Something has happened to your world…”

We know, of course, that at the end of The Flash, the DCEU gets a George Clooney Batman. But what happens to Affleck’s Batman? And what happens to his Gotham?

Wait and see.